Case Study Grading Rubric

This chart is based on the assignment/instructions that I posted on the blog, as well as the parameters I laid out in class meetings. Please keep in mind that this is a general guideline for how I am grading your papers and presentations, so each comment may not specifically apply to your paper. In other words, if you received anything less than an 'A' on your paper, it means that you met one or more of the criteria I outline in each section below (but not necessarily all of them).

-Papers-
Grade: A
• Your topic is specific, focused and well thought out.
• Your thesis is clear and the organization of your paper is logical, coherent and organized.
• You effectively apply a theoretical concept, or concepts, from the course in your analysis.
• You make effective use of primary and secondary research to supplement your argument and lay out your position.
• Your resources are appropriate for a college level course and are appropriately cited.
• Your writing is free of spelling and grammatical errors.

Grade: B
• Your topic is focused and well thought out.
• Your thesis is clear but the organization of your paper could use some work.
• You make use of a concept or concepts from the course, but they need to be better explained and/or situated within your analysis.
• Your research is adequate but you primarily relied on course assignments without doing extensive research.
• Your resources are appropriate for a college level course and are appropriately cited.
• Your writing contains a few spelling and/or grammatical problems.

Grade: C
• Your topic is not entirely clear and is either unspecific or only loosely connected to our coursework.
• Your thesis is not pronounced and your organization needs considerable work.
• You make reference to a theoretical concept or concepts from the course but you do not explain them well or use them effectively.
• You did the bare minimum of research for your paper and the materials do not contribute a great deal to your argument.
• Your resources are appropriate for a college level course, but are not appropriately quoted, cited or integrated into your paper.
• Your paper does not include a formal bibliography or list of works cited.
• Your paper needs to be proofread for spelling and/or grammatical errors.

Grade: D
• Your topic is either too vague or only loosely connected to our coursework.
• Your paper does not have a clear thesis and/or is poorly organized.
• You do not make a clear connection between your topic and a theoretical concept or concepts from the course.
• You paper is not well researched and makes no reference to reading materials assigned during the semester.
• Your resources are not appropriate for a college level course and are not appropriately used (or cited) in your paper.
• Your paper does not include a bibliography or list of works cited.
• Your paper has numerous spelling and grammatical errors.

Grade: F
• Your topic is unclear and/or unrelated to our coursework.
• Your paper suffers from a lack of clarity and/or organization.
• You make no clear connection between your topic and any theoretical concepts from the course.
• Your paper demonstrates a general lack of research.
• Your resources are inappropriate for a college level course, i.e. are most likely taken from random sites on the Internet or have little intellectual relevance to our course.
• Your paper suffers from a variety of spelling and grammatical problems and is clearly not proofread.
• Your paper does not include a bibliography or list of works cited.

Grade: Zero
• You either did not turn in the assignment or plagiarized material in your paper.



-Presentations-
Grade: A
Your presentation was well prepared and well delivered.
• You clearly laid out your argument and gave an excellent synopsis of your paper.
• You made sure to define and/or explain your topic with specific reference to the theory (or theories) you utilized in your paper.

Grade: B
• Your presentation was generally good but could have been better prepared or organized.
• You gave a pretty good synopsis of your paper and your argument.
• Your description of the topic and/or the concepts used in your analysis was effective, but could use some work.

Grade: C
• Your presentation was mediocre, meaning it was not that well prepared and did not provide a substantial amount of detail, background or context.
• You adequately described your topic but did not properly explain your argument or the concepts used in your analysis.

Grade: D
• Your presentation showed a general lack of preparation and provided your audience with only a vague overview of your topic and your argument.
• You failed to make any clear connection between your topic and any of the concepts we discussed this semester.

Grade: F
• You presentation was not prepared and it is clear that you did not take this aspect of the assignment seriously.
• You did not provide a clear description of either your topic, your paper, or any of the concepts from our course.

Grade: Zero
• You did not deliver your presentation and did not provide me with any legitimate (documented) excuse for doing so.